Journal · · 3 min ← All posts

The 6 cap that loses to a Treasury

The safest-looking deal I saw this month, why I passed, and the building I bought with the same problem.

By Brent Neely

Last week a broker sent me the deal that gets sold as the safe one. New construction, one national tenant on a 15-year lease, and the tenant pays the taxes, insurance and maintenance. About $7.5 million at a 6 cap.

I passed in a weekend. Here’s the test that killed it.

The two-number test

Leverage comes down to two numbers: the cap rate, and the rate on the loan.

A 6 cap means a $100 building earns $6 a year if you pay cash. Borrow below 6%, and the bank’s money makes you money. Borrow above it, and it costs you.

A $100 building at a 6 cap with a 75% interest-only loan. At a 3% rate you earn 15% on your $25. At 6% you earn 6%, the same as paying cash. At 7% you earn 3%.Same building, three loansA $100 building at a 6 cap, 75% borrowed, interest only. What you earn on your $25.All cash: 6%Loan at 3%: interest $2.25, you keep $3.75 on $25, 15%Loan at 3%15%Loan at 6%: interest $4.50, you keep $1.50 on $25, 6%. The loan does nothing.Loan at 6%6%Loan at 7%: interest $5.25, you keep $0.75 on $25, 3%Loan at 7%3%Simplified example. Ignores principal payments, closing costs and taxes.

That’s positive and negative leverage. Same building, same rent. The loan decides whether you make 15% or 3%.

The deal I passed on

The 10-year Treasury paid just under 5%. The building earns a 6.0% cap rate. The loan costs about 6.5%, more than the building earns.The loan costs more than the building earnsNew construction, one national tenant, 15-year lease, about $7.5 million10-year Treasury, week of October 26: just under 5%, liquid10-year Treasuryjust under 5%Cap rate: 6.0% in year oneWhat the building earns6.0% cap rateLoan at today's terms: about 6.5%What the loan costs6.5% rateTreasury: MarketWatch, October 26, 2026. Loan: 60% of price, 6.5%, 25-year amortization.

With a normal loan, the payment eats most of the rent. What’s left is about 2.8% on the cash I’d put in, while the Treasury paid just under 5%, liquid, with no roof to replace.

Three more things. The 10% rent bump every five years doesn’t close the gap. The guarantor is rated below investment grade, but the deal is priced as if it isn’t. And when the tenant pays everything, there’s nothing for an owner to improve.

For this deal to work, the price has to come down. The seller’s building costs went up too, so I don’t think it will.

The building I bought anyway

Aspen, our 45-unit building in Boise, had the same problem on day one.

On the seller's trailing 12 months, Aspen's cap rate on what we paid was 5.63%, below the 6.24% loan rate. September, the first full month, annualized to 6.42%. The underwriting projects 6.78% in year one and 7.59% in year two.Aspen: from headwind to tailwindCap rate on what we paid, against our 6.24% loan rateLoan rate 6.24%Seller's trailing 12 months: 5.63% on the $8.75M price, below the 6.24% rateSeller's last 12 months5.63%September net operating income times 12, on the $8.75M price: 6.42%September, our first month6.42%, actualYear one, underwritten: 6.78%Year one, our plan6.78%Year two, underwritten: 7.59%Year two, our plan7.59%September is one month of net operating income, times 12. Years one and two are underwriting projections, not results.

I bought it because the plan fixed the gap in year one without needing the market to help. We changed the management structure, cut insurance about 40%, and stopped carrying full-time salaried staff. September, our first full month, ran at a 6.42% cap rate on what we paid. The gap closed in month one.

That’s the difference. Negative leverage with no plan is a bet that the market bails you out. I don’t make that bet.

If you want to learn more about Aspen, here’s the deal page.

I recorded a full episode of the Wealth Cockpit on this, out Wednesday, November 4. If you’re looking at a deal and want a second set of eyes on the two numbers, grab 30 minutes, or just email me.

Book 30 minutes with me

Or email hello@neelypi.com.

Thanks,
Brent


This is not investment or tax advice. Aspen year-one and year-two figures are underwriting projections, not results, and are not guaranteed. Neely Property Investments offerings are made under Rule 506(c) to verified accredited investors only.

A short personal note from me most Fridays about what actually happened that week. Subscribe to the Friday letter.

·

Recent posts

How to invest passively in Boise apartments

If you're an accredited investor, the usual way to invest passively in a Boise apartment building is as a limited partner alongside a sponsor who buys it and runs it, typically with a $50,000 minimum. Here's how that works, what the fees usually look like, and why the sponsor's operating record matters more than their deal flow.

Boise apartments are 98.3% full. Four of five deals still didn't sell.

Boise apartment vacancy fell from 4.3% to 1.7% in a year, and rents are up 10%. Most of the apartment buildings that came up for sale still didn't sell. The same thing explains both: interest rates.

A document from 1990 cost my title insurance company $185,000. Here's how chain of title works.

Every building has a paper trail at the county. Months after I bought an office building, the City sent me a letter citing a 1990 agreement nobody had caught. Here's how title works, and how a $185,000 claim played out.