Boise apartments are 98.3% full. Four of five deals still didn't sell.
By Brent Neely
Here are two numbers from Boise this fall that don’t seem to go together.
Apartments in Boise are 98.3% occupied. A year ago it was 95.7%. Rents are up 10.1%.
And of the 22 apartment buildings over 25 units that came up for sale in Boise this year, about five sold.
Both are true, and interest rates explain both. High rates keep people renting. High rates also keep buyers and sellers from agreeing on a price. If you’re thinking about owning apartments here, that’s the thing to understand right now.
What rates did to buying a house
In January 2021, the mortgage payment on a typical Boise home was $1,455 a month with 10% down. Typical rent was $1,354. Owning and renting cost about the same.
Today that payment is $3,050. Boise home values are up 26% since then, and the 30-year rate went from 2.73% to 7.18%. Typical rent is $1,900. Owning now costs $1,150 more every month, before taxes and insurance.
A gap like that keeps a lot of people renting who’d otherwise buy. Some of the people filling Boise apartments right now would’ve bought a house in 2021.
That’s one reason the vacancy chart above moved so fast. The other reason is supply.
Boise stopped permitting apartments
Boise permitted about 3,700 apartment units from 2021 through 2023. Those buildings opened over the last two years, and for a while landlords were handing out free months to fill them.
Then the permits dried up. Boise city permitted 248 apartment units in 2024 and 195 in 2025. Through August 2026 it’s at 220.
In September I wrote that permits were still falling. I was half right. That post used Ada and Canyon counties together, and across both counties permits have turned back up. Canyon County pulled 690 of the 1,218 units permitted across the two counties in 2025. Kuna and Nampa are building again.
Boise isn’t, much. 220 units through August is up from last year’s 163 for the same months. It’s still a sliver of the 1,430 Boise permitted in 2023. Apartments open about two years after the permit, so Boise’s new supply stays thin through 2027 at least.
The buildings that are going up skew new and expensive. About 1,900 apartments are under construction across the valley, and all of it is rated 3 Star or better. Nothing new is going up in the older 1 and 2 Star buildings. That’s what I buy.
Here’s the tradeoff I’m choosing. Renters in older buildings are the most sensitive to price. A 10% year doesn’t mean a 10% year in a C building, and I’m not planning on another one. Rents across the valley have also dipped 2% to 5% every winter since 2022. A soft December would be normal.
The same rates hit buyers like me
Rates explain why the buildings aren’t selling, too.
Owners want something close to 2022 prices. Buyers are borrowing at 2026 rates. I locked Aspen’s loan at 6.24% in August. A month later, the same loan would have priced about a point higher. On a building whose rent barely covers the loan, that point is the whole deal.
So buildings get listed, offers come in, and the seller pulls it when the number isn’t the one they remember. Buyers are out there. A newer 160-unit building in Nampa drew 31 offers and closed in September. The buildings that trade are the ones where the seller priced to today.
What I’m doing with my own money
I’m bidding, and I’m losing some.
This fall I was the second-best offer on a portfolio. The seller went with a national buyer that already had seven other deals under contract with them. When a seller is moving a lot of buildings, a buyer they already trust to close beats a better number. I’d make the same offer again.
I walked away from another deal after finding a large deferred maintenance bill that wasn’t in the marketing. The seller was pushing for a nonrefundable deposit on day one at the same time. If you want me to go hard, give me all the information.
What I’m looking for is an owner with a real reason to sell. A loan coming due, a partnership ending, a fund running out of time. I wrote about why those owners are coming last week. They price to 2026.
Here’s how I see it. High rates are keeping renters in apartments, and Boise isn’t building many new ones. A building bought at today’s price, on a loan that works today, sits on the right side of both.
See the building I bought this year
Aspen is 45 units in Boise, on a fixed-rate loan, with a plan that works at today's rates. If you want to talk about what's next, book 30 minutes or email me at hello@neelypi.com.
Market data: RealPage via Berkadia, Boise Multifamily Market Report Q3 2026; U.S. Census Bureau Building Permits Survey; Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey; Zillow; CoStar. This is not investment advice. Neely Property Investments offerings are made under Rule 506(c) to verified accredited investors only.
If you're an accredited investor, the usual way to invest passively in a Boise apartment building is as a limited partner alongside a sponsor who buys it and runs it, typically with a $50,000 minimum. Here's how that works, what the fees usually look like, and why the sponsor's operating record matters more than their deal flow.
Every building has a paper trail at the county. Months after I bought an office building, the City sent me a letter citing a 1990 agreement nobody had caught. Here's how title works, and how a $185,000 claim played out.
In October a Blackstone apartment loan hit its due date and couldn't be paid off. It isn't the only one. Here's what's happening to loans written in 2021, and why that's the best setup for buyers I've seen in years.