Journal · · 5 min ← All posts

We took Aspen apart on paper. Here's what the engineer found.

An engineer walked our 45-unit Boise building and counted every dishwasher, cabinet and square foot of carpet. Here's what that count does for the people who own the building with us.

By Brent Neely

This isn't tax advice. It's a primer for the conversation with your CPA.

On October 21, an engineer walked Aspen with our property manager and a clipboard. His numbers were in my inbox the next morning.

It's called a cost segregation study. It costs $5,000, and for our investors it's probably the most valuable piece of paper this deal produces all year.

A building isn't one thing

The IRS lets you write off an apartment building a little at a time, over 27.5 years. But a building is also dishwashers, carpet, cabinets and a parking lot, and those wear out a lot faster. The tax code lets you write those pieces off faster too. You just have to count them first. That's the study.

What we actually bought

Red pieces get written off in 2026. Blue pieces take 27.5 years. Hover any marker.

What goes into an apartment building A cutaway of an apartment building. Marked in red and written off in 2026: appliances, cabinets and countertops, kitchen sinks, carpet and vinyl floors, ceiling fans, window blinds, the parking lot and sidewalks, the carport, landscaping, fencing and storm drains. Marked in blue and written off over 27.5 years: the roof, exterior walls and windows, drywall and paint, plumbing lines, wiring and lighting, heating and cooling, and the foundation and framing. CUTAWAY, GROUND-FLOOR UNIT 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 A B C D E F G

Written off in 2026

  • 1Appliances
  • 2Cabinets and countertops
  • 3Kitchen sinks
  • 4Carpet and vinyl floors
  • 5Ceiling fans
  • 6Window blinds
  • 7Parking lot and sidewalks
  • 8Carport
  • 9Landscaping
  • 10Fencing
  • 11Storm drains

Written off over 27.5 years

  • ARoof
  • BExterior walls and windows
  • CDrywall and paint
  • DPlumbing lines
  • EWiring and lighting
  • FHeating and cooling
  • GFoundation and framing

Plumbing, drywall, paint and the roof are part of the structure, so they stay on the long schedule. What moves fast is everything that wears out or gets replaced: the kitchen, the floors, the parking lot, the landscaping. Add those up and you get the split below.

Where the $8.75 million purchase price went

Hover a section for detail

Land

Never depreciates. It comes off the top.

Fast

Appliances, cabinets, flooring, paving, landscaping. Written off in 2026.

The structure

Walls, roof, foundation. A small slice every year for 27.5 years.

Without the study, all of that red would sit in the blue. Same building. Very different first year.

He counted

This is the part I wanted you to see. The number is a count. Every line cites the standard construction cost manual it came from, so an auditor can retrace it.

45
dishwashers, at $637 each
990 ft
of base and wall cabinets
15,218
square feet of carpet
A page of line items from the study: 45 dishwashers at $637 each, cabinets priced by the linear foot, carpet by the square foot, each with a cost-manual source.
An actual page from the study. These are replacement costs. The engineer then adds a builder's soft costs and scales everything to what we paid.

What it changes in year one

Under current law, those fast pieces can be written off all at once in the year the building goes into service. Aspen went into service August 28, 2026.

Depreciation the building produces in 2026

Same building, same price

About 25 times the first-year write-off, from a $5,000 report.

What it means if you own Aspen with us

The depreciation passes through to our investors in proportion to what they put in. It works out like this.

About 89 cents of first-year depreciation for every dollar invested.

We don't buy buildings for the depreciation

If the tax piece were the only reason, I wouldn't have bought Aspen, and I wouldn't have put my own money in it. We bought it because the rents in place were below market, we have a plan to close that gap as units turn over, and it pays investors monthly. The depreciation sits on top of all that.

See the full Aspen deal →

What decides what it's worth to you

The depreciation is the same for every investor. What it does on each return isn't. Three things drive it.

Your bracket

The $88,700 reduces taxable income. Your bracket sets what that's worth in dollars.

Your passive income

For most investors it's a passive loss. It offsets other passive income, like rentals, and anything unused carries forward until the building sells.

The eventual sale

When the building sells, part of the depreciation comes back as recapture. The value is in the timing, and what the money does in between.

The fund allocates the number. Your CPA applies it.

Talking to your CPA before December 31?

I wrote a one-page summary for exactly that conversation. Hand it to your CPA, or book 30 minutes and I'll walk you through it.

I planned for 60 cents. It came in at 89.

When I underwrote Aspen, I told our investors to expect about 60 cents of first-year depreciation for every dollar they put in. I picked a number I was confident we'd beat.

First-year depreciation per dollar invested

What I forecast vs. what the study found

That's how I try to underwrite every deal. Conservative on the things I can't control, so when the real number shows up, it lands in our investors' favor.

See the other pages from the study
Asset summary page: land, 5-year, 15-year and 27.5-year costs.
The summary page. "Fast" in the chart above is the 5-year and 15-year lines added together.
Year-one bonus depreciation table: $2,643,806 with cost segregation versus $103,420 without.
The year-one table.

Thanks,
   Brent

This is not tax advice. Talk to your CPA about your situation. The $100,000 example assumes the fund's full member capital of $2,979,986.

A short personal note from me most Fridays about what actually happened that week. Subscribe to the Friday letter.

·

Recent posts

How to invest passively in Boise apartments

If you're an accredited investor, the usual way to invest passively in a Boise apartment building is as a limited partner alongside a sponsor who buys it and runs it, typically with a $50,000 minimum. Here's how that works, what the fees usually look like, and why the sponsor's operating record matters more than their deal flow.

Boise apartments are 98.3% full. Four of five deals still didn't sell.

Boise apartment vacancy fell from 4.3% to 1.7% in a year, and rents are up 10%. Most of the apartment buildings that came up for sale still didn't sell. The same thing explains both: interest rates.

A document from 1990 cost my title insurance company $185,000. Here's how chain of title works.

Every building has a paper trail at the county. Months after I bought an office building, the City sent me a letter citing a 1990 agreement nobody had caught. Here's how title works, and how a $185,000 claim played out.