The Wealth Cockpit · Episode 7

Most deals today lose money on the loan. You can check it with two numbers.

Cover art for Most deals today lose money on the loan. You can check it with two numbers.
Most deals today lose money on the loan. You can check it with two numbers.
12 min 48 sec Download MP3

Show notes

Most deals today cost more to borrow on than the building earns. That's negative leverage. I walk through a $100 example, a 6 cap single-tenant building I passed on this week, and Aspen, a building I bought in August that was negative leverage on the day I closed, and the plan that's built to flip it. Year-one and year-two figures are projections, not results. The test is two numbers: the cap rate on the real trailing twelve months, and the rate on your loan. Want the one-page Leverage Check? Email wealthcockpit@neelypi.com and tell me a bit about where you are in this. Illustrative examples only, not an offer to sell a security. Returns are targeted, not promised.

Transcript

SPEAKER_00 0:00

In this episode of the Wealth Cockpit, I I get into the uh details and maybe a little nitty-gritty of what cap rates are and what negative leverage is and how that is so important and relevant in today's rate environment. So uh if you want to learn a little bit more about real estate investing and what that might look like today and how negative leverage and debt in general affects your investment, then uh stay tuned. I think you're in for a real treat. Hey guys, welcome back to the uh wealth cockpit where we uh plan the flight before we take off. Today I thought it'd be really interesting to talk about uh negative leverage and what that means in relation to investing in real estate and our current rate environments uh with the treasury kind of continually to tick up and um kind of be the new norm that it seems, and how negative leverage affects a real estate investment and just just how that works. So uh what kind of brought this up is I had a broker send me a uh a six cap property, which if you don't know what a cap rate is, um I have more information on my website, you can look that up. But basically, what kind of return a property would give uh if you paid cash for it. So um if you buy a property for $100 at a six cap, that means you're gonna earn six dollars a year in net income. So it's a little more complicated than that and all the variables that go into it, but um that's what a a cap rate is. So uh we'll get back into that a little bit more in a minute. Um, but I also close Aspen apartments. Uh it's been a couple months now, and there's some interesting uh conversation about negative leverage there. So um just want to kind of have a conversation and help explain this topic as it's becoming more and more important uh with uh today's environment of investing in real estate. I put together uh the show notes and some more examples. Uh if you'd like to get those from me, shoot me an email at wealthcockpit at nealypi.com. But uh basically positive leverage is when your cap rate is higher than your interest rate. This is a huge part of real estate investment. Um, this is what uh can allow you to make outsized returns. If you look at in today's environment, if you are gonna buy a property like like this property was was really low risk, it was a national tenant, uh, it's a build to suit right now, so which means that the uh contractor is currently building the property uh to suit this tenant, uh, has a 15-year lease, you know, all those things are are great. Um, but at a six cap, I'm getting a six percent return on my money if I pay cash, and I can go get five percent in a treasury and have it completely liquid. So, in my opinion, that's not enough of a premium to make my money um illiquid for 10 plus years. Um, and you're taking on some other risk of the um the capital expenses of the building wearing down and that sort of thing. But um so I want to give a real a real clear, this is a simplified but clear example, and there's quite a few numbers in here, so stick with me. But um, if this property costs me $100 and I keep uh six dollars in net income at the end of the year, that's a six six percent cap rate, and I earn six percent on my money. Um, if I leverage that property, so say I take a loan out for 75% of the property, and say that's at a 7% interest rate, which you know it might even be higher in today's rate environment, but but probably around a 7%. So I only have to put in $25, but I have to pay the interest, and then the uh you know what's left over in this example is I keep 75 cents, which is 3%. So the bank's money that I'm borrowing is costing me more than the income that that property is getting me. Uh in this case, they had a 10% um price uh escalation in the lease every five years. It doesn't overcome that negative leverage when the debt is costing you more than the income the property is giving you. So uh let me give you on the flip side of this, right? Um, if I could borrow 75% of the money to buy this property, so $75 on my $100 property uh at 3% interest, right? Now uh I put in $25, uh, the interest cost me $2.25, and I'm keeping $3.75, which equates to a 15% return on my money. So I'm earning 6% on the $25 I put in, and I'm earning the difference on the bank's money because I'm only paying them three. And that's what positive leverage does, and that is one of the huge advantages to real estate investing when you have this consistent cash flow and you can also leverage it and make make money on the bank's money. So I'm gonna say that that's getting harder and harder to find with treasuries uh going up, which means all the lending and the lenders are charging more, and sellers that own these properties have had these valued at certain cap rates, you know, which varies depending on the market and and the area. Um, you know, generally it's between a four and a ten cap, it's is you know most commercial real estate, but um, it varies by the market. But the these sellers, you know, don't want to sell for a lot cheaper, um, which is equates to a higher cap rate because you know they they saw what their property was worth a few years ago, five years ago, when interest rates were three percent and money was was really, really cheap. Um so there's this spread between bid and ask on what buyers are willing to pay, what sellers want to sell for that has has kind of frozen up some of the market. So um giving you a uh a flying analogy here, debt is the wind when we're flying. So it's the same plane, same engine, same fuel. Positive leverage can be a huge tailwind. Uh you get there much, much faster. Just with my example, you go from a 6% return to a 15% return on your money. And negative leverage can be a massive headwind. You can use have the same engine, same throttle, um, but over the ground you are going significantly slower and only earning 3% on your money, where it would have been better to buy it with all cash. So negative uh leverage can really damage a real estate investment. And you know, the wind is one of those things that we don't have a lot of control over over uh real estate investors, which makes it all the more important that the entry and the purchase price uh today takes into account our rate environments and uh stress tests, you know, what if rates go up? So that's my flying analogy. Uh that's why I passed on this uh triple net six cap deal that um you know, with 3% debt available, could cash flow uh tremendously well and be a fantastic investment. But at a six cap with seven percent leverage, um it's really not. So there needs to be uh a pricing adjustment on uh for that seller, and I'm just not sure that they're willing to do it because at the same time, you know, building costs have gone up and all these other costs that they have when they're looking to make a profit. So there are a few um kind of diamonds in the rough today in uh real estate investing. There are some loans out there that are uh assumable. I was just looking at a deal, um, an apartment complex that had an assumable about a 3.5% loan uh on it, which means that I could buy that property, I could take that loan over and um have really strong positive leverage. Uh the challenge is a lot of buyers are are paying a premium for that. So where that property you know might really be worth a uh five and three quarter cap uh today, you know, it's getting bid down to a four and three quarter cap. So it cash flows really well. Um, but you're really making this bet that in five or seven years when that loan expires and you've used up all that value, that uh cap rates, you know, and interest rates have come down and compressed. And you know, that was just a bet I wasn't comfortable um making. But there are some assumable loans uh out there where you know they can be a great deal, and I'm definitely uh continuing to look for those. The other um strategy in today's market is where you can add value. So when you look at this uh triple net, which means that the tenant pays everything, you know, what can you do to that property to make it more valuable, make it have better income? And the answer is uh is pretty much nothing. Um on the flip side, a value add property, um, which you know I have a lot of operational background, business background, and I love implementing a business plan and watching it execute. Um the aspen that I just bought uh two months ago, it's a 45 unit property. If you look strictly on the um the T12, so the trailing 12-month uh income that the seller was running it, I was at a 5.63% cap rate. And um I got a really good loan on it, um, I I feel, but the the interest rate is 6.24%. So between those two numbers uh is negative leverage, and you know, we just talked about what a headwind that can be. So um, and I'll explain why I did that. The I I wouldn't do that without a plan to be able to turn that around day one. So um our year one underwriting for a couple reasons, uh I believe that we could get that income up substantially, and we could turn that into a 6.78% uh the cap rate on uh you know after I took it over and was able to change some stuff immediately. So now we're talking about a 50 basis point positive leverage, and in year two that gap widens due to rent growth to a 7.59% uh cap rate. So a big uh portion of that was changing the management structure that I had in that property and being able to reduce expenses. So it isn't just relying on, hey, I could raise rents this much and the market rent is gonna grow that much, and you know, all these things. I I reduced my insurance cost by 40%. Um I implemented a different manager that I don't have, I'm not carrying full-time uh salaried employees, and we exceeded our projections in month one based on the expenses that we were able to cut. So I, you know, I was able to find a deal that um looked like negative leverage day one, but able to uh implement a plan uh to turn that to positive leverage. And that is um that's my whole thesis is like really um negative leverage is is unacceptable. A negative leverage is um is gambling where you're you're gonna just hope that the market will grow and outgrow it and bail you out. So I would challenge you, a if you're looking at uh commercial real estate properties, you really key in on those numbers. And and cap rates can be a little deceiving. Um, you know, brokers will put pro forma cap rates on there and um and all sorts of different things. But if you just take the the actual sellers, T12, um sometimes you have to dig into those numbers to make sure that they've included all the expenses like property taxes and insurance and things. But if you take the real T12, um last 12 months of income divided by the purchase price, um, that's the cap rate. Is that larger or smaller than the interest rate on the loan that you're getting? And um if the cap rate's lower, you better have a good plan to turn that around and um, you know, increase that income uh in a very short period of time so you're not sitting there with negative leverage. So again, if you'd like these show notes um or like more information, uh like to sit set up a call and and have a chat, then uh I'd love for you to uh shoot me an email at wealthcockpit at nealypi dot com. I'll send you over the show notes, uh no questions asked, and um look forward to connecting.

Disclosure

Securities offered under Rule 506(c) of Regulation D. Available only to verified accredited investors. This page is for informational purposes only and does not constitute an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any securities. Any such offer would be made solely pursuant to a Private Placement Memorandum and related subscription documents. Real estate investing involves risk, including the potential loss of principal. Projections are forward-looking statements based on assumptions that may not prove accurate. Past performance is not indicative of future results.